Hidden Meaning in BIRDMAN – Earthling Cinema


Greetings, and welcome to Earthling Cinema. I am your host, Garyx Wormuloid. This week’s artifact is Birdman, the Oscar-winning
masterpiece directed by British prankster Ali G. Inarritu. The film follows Riggan Thomson, a mentally
ill former movie star who puts on a Broadstreet play in an attempt to jumpstart his car. What? Oh, not car. Career. Riggan surrounds himself with yes men, like
his best friend, his girlfriend, even his daughter. There’s one guy Riggan doesn’t like, so he
murders him with a light fixture. They have a few previews, which is when you
do a fake show for a bunch of freeloaders. Riggan gets locked outside in Walter Whities,
but fortunately, it goes viral, which is good, even though usually on Earth viruses were
bad. A mean critic from the Earth Herald Gazette
tells Riggan she’ll write him a bad review no matter what, even if he goes on a reflective
journey that leads him to a bold self-sacrifice. So Riggan gets plastered and imagines himself
flying around like some sort of…bug? Bug is another word for virus. On the day of the big premiere, Riggan tells
his ex-wife that he tried to kill himself in a not at all suspicious way. Then he goes onstage for his suicide scene,
but he brings a real gun instead of a prop gun. Also not suspicious. But then out of nowhere, he fucking shoots
himself in the head! Everyone cheers because they’re so surprised. Riggan wakes up in the hospital feeling much
better, other than the loss of his mouth awning. The play got a rave review for its “super
realism” — a shitty superpower, by the way — and now his family likes him again. Riggan tells Birdman to go jump in a lake,
which is basically the worst thing you can say to a bird, since birds and fish are mortal
enemies. Then he climbs out the small glass door in
the wall. Moments later, his daughter looks outside
and sees a funny billboard. Birdman creates a meta-textual conversation
through its casting of Buster Keaton’s son Michael as the main dude. Just as Riggan was famous for playing Birdman,
Keaton had starred in the blockbuster hits Batman 1 and Batman Comes Back to Town. Both Riggan and Keaton left their comic book
stardom behind in the name of artistic integrity, and both subsequently dropped off the face
of the Earth. Figuratively, of course, since humans were
still decades away from developing an interplanetary slingshot. This meta-textual layer cake contributes to
a greater dichotomy within the film kitchen: reality versus fantasy. The movie was edited to appear as though it
was filmed in one continuous shot, invoking the authenticity of live theater. At the same time, the single-shot technique
lends a dreamlike quality that makes you feel like you’re falling and all your teeth are
made of Jello. Certain sequences appear natural at first
glance, but upon closer inspection prove to be impossible given Earth’s physics. For instance, Mike goes from doing a little
hankity pankity up in the rafters one moment, to appearing onstage the next. Similarly, at first we think the drumming
is simply the film’s soundtrack, no big whoop. We’ve all heard stick music before. But when the action sweeps by a drummer playing
the very notes we’re hearing, it becomes unclear what is being experienced by the characters
and what we are hallucinating because we just OD’ed on ludes. Mike Shiner embodies the “reality” of the
theater, and he keeps ’em bodies tight. When he’s performing, he drinks real liqour
and tries to commit real sexual assault. He frequently berates Riggan for being fake,
never once turning to wink to the camera to let us know he’s Edward Norton and the whole
thing’s just a goof. While Riggan is annoyed by Mike’s antics,
he appreciates the need to sacrifice in order to deliver a genuine performance. His race through Times Quadrangle in his tankini
bottoms is a metaphor for acting, where one must strip away all inhibitions and let randos
see the outline of your forbidden zone, or “dong.” In shooting himself onstage, Riggan is lauded
for his authenticity, if not his marksmanship. But in fact, he is simply giving people the
same blood, guts and cheap thrills he gave them in his blockbusters. There is no difference between a “lowbrow”
film or “high art” theater; it’s all a performance done to win valuable hand claps. This point is underlined by Riggan’s bandages. Even after being deemed a true artist, he
still wears Birdman’s mask. Only now he has returned as Birdman the White. Additionally, Riggan has come to embody the
character he won’t shut up about in his play, looking at the woman he loves through his
stupid eyeholes. Ultimately, both of his characters are simply
costumes that obscure who he really is: a guy with a purple honker. The ending of the film is left deliberately
ambiguous. Does Riggan die, and merely imagine that his
daughter sees him as he sees himself, flying triumphantly over the city? Or, having achieved success and made peace
with his family, is Riggan’s flight actually real? Did they cast Emma Stone just because her
eyes are so damn big? All these question and more, answered next
time! Just kidding. For Earthling Cinema, I’m Garyx Wormuloid… Ca-caw! CA-CAW!

Maurice Vega

100 Responses

  1. Thank you for putting my comment up there, I'm sincerely jazzed about that. I love all your guys' videos, with Thug Notes reigniting my interest in classic literature, and Earthling Cinema allowing me to understand these works in a new light.

  2. I think that the ending was an abstract way of saying that he can finally share his artistic imagination with his daughter smoothly.

  3. But how could I possibly miss a meaning when the movie reminded me and shoved it down my throats every five seconds

  4. MatPat? Handsome? With those eyebrows? I mean, I guess if you're into that sort of thing…

    Just kidding! Love you both! Such great content! Such eyebrows! Much win. Yes.

  5. the other thing is that they made a movie about a classic cartoon superhero without the superhero in the golden era of action movies.

  6. I never did realise that the very thing that theatre goers hate (big action set pieces), they were given and gave a standing ovation for. Just goes to show that ignorance is bliss.

  7. What did he say at 2.04 about the ending, that her daughter looks outside and sees a funny billboard..HAHAHAHA..ROFL

  8. every time I think of this movie I can't help, but think if the hanna barbara bird man and the adultswim show!

  9. Now I see why you put these greens antenas in the beginning. They hypnotize the viewer to keep watching your videos! And it works! Just watched 2hrs non stop. Shame on you Garyx, shame on you. .

  10. Wisecrack, you guys should do "The Egga And I". Not only is it a funny story, but it spun off the whole Ma and Pa Kettle series. What other film has thirteen sequels?

  11. …It's Bird Person, not Birdman. Well, technically, Phoenix Person, now. Gah, nobody gets it right, not even the movie!

  12. So none of these "Hidden Meanings" are on horror, thrillers, and sci fi movies. Is it that there's no meaning in these genres? If not, doooooo Robocop?

  13. The birdman finally set himself free. Every events after he jumped off the window is his projections on how things would occur. His daughter being amazed is not her conscience but rather its his.
    Outside his projections in the real world, of course he would be found dead at the bottom, and she would be grieving. But in his projections he would be flying, and she would be amazed. Hed like to believe that when he jumped, all his sorrows should die with it. He will not take any responsibility on someones grief , and other consequences on peoples live following his jump. So he created, a false projections of what would happen following his jump, hold on firmly to the belief, and without a second thought before he changed his projections , swiftly jumped off the window. Her momrntary ambiguity was soon blessed with the pleasant surprise.

  14. Anchorman (regarding Emma Stone): It's terrible – she has beautiful eyes, and her hair smells like cinnamon!

    But for real, Emma was gorge in that movie!!

  15. I know I am writing this super late. Birdman is heavily influenced by magicrealism. A southamerican style of writing

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Post comment